Hiring a criminal defense attorney can be a daunting task. From a defense attorney’s perspective, what types of questions should you be asking? First and foremost, it’s important to understand that having a clear picture of your case is essential for a meaningful consultation. Asking an attorney to give legal advice based on limited, false, or vague information is risky—it can lead to confusion and complicate an already overwhelming situation.
Below are some of the questions I recommend my own friends and family ask when searching for a defense attorney. Keep in mind that every case is different, and legal advice depends heavily on a range of factors, such as the jurisdiction and the underlying facts of the alleged offense.
That said, honesty is key. You should be forthright with your defense attorney about your situation so they can provide you with the best advice possible. Let them know what your goals are—whether you’re aiming to take the case to trial or hoping for a negotiated resolution. Tailor your questions to those goals. For example, if you’re leaning toward trial, focus on the attorney’s courtroom experience.
Eight Smart Questions to Ask Your Criminal Defense Attorney
- What is your experience with cases like mine? This question helps you determine whether the attorney has handled similar cases and knows how to navigate the issues you’re facing.
- What types of law do you practice? Criminal law is a highly specialized area. While all attorneys receive some training in it, only those who regularly handle criminal cases truly understand its nuances. You’ll want someone who is not just a generalist but who has specific, courtroom-tested experience in criminal defense.
- How often do you work in this jurisdiction? Every California county operates a bit differently. An attorney who regularly appears in the courthouse where your case is pending is more likely to have established relationships with prosecutors, judges, and court staff—relationships that can significantly influence case outcomes.
- What would your strategy be in a case like mine? This gives insight into how the attorney thinks and whether their approach aligns with your goals and values. A thoughtful, transparent explanation is a good sign.
- If hired who will be handling my case? It’s important to know who you’re actually hiring. One of the most common complaints clients have is being surprised when unfamiliar attorneys appear in court. While occasional scheduling adjustments are normal, your attorney should be upfront about who will handle each stage of the case.
- What are your fees, and do you offer payment plans? Make sure you understand whether you’re being charged a flat fee or hourly rate. Read the contract carefully and ask questions. Knowing what’s expected of you—and what you can expect in return—helps avoid surprises later.
- How will you communicate with me, and how can I reach you? Communication issues are the number one complaint against attorneys. Set expectations early. Ask how updates will be delivered and what method of contact (email, phone, text) is preferred.
- Why should I hire you over another criminal defense lawyer? This question invites the attorney to highlight what sets them apart—whether it’s experience, courtroom success, client service, or a personalized approach. It also helps you better understand the value you’re getting.
Final Thoughts
No matter what questions you choose to ask, remember that hiring an attorney isn’t just about credentials. It’s also about fit. Your attorney should be someone you trust, feel comfortable with, and can communicate openly with. For example, if your communication styles clash or your expectations differ significantly, it’s better to realize that early than after retaining them.
Also, do your research. Online reviews (Google, Yelp, etc.) can offer valuable insight from past clients about their experiences. Pay attention to feedback about professionalism, responsiveness, and case outcomes.
At Chastaine | Jones, we pride ourselves on transparency, dedication, and strategic advocacy. We believe in guiding clients, not selling to them. If you’re facing criminal charges, the right attorney can not only help you achieve the best possible result but can also reduce the stress and uncertainty you’re experiencing throughout the process.
FAQ for “Questions to Ask a Criminal Defense Attorney in Sacramento”
When hiring a criminal defense attorney in Sacramento, it’s natural to have questions. Common concerns include how to choose the right lawyer, what experience they have with cases like yours, who will handle your case, how fees and payment plans work, and how they communicate throughout the process. Asking the right questions not only helps you find an attorney you trust but also ensures their strategy aligns with your goals, giving you confidence and clarity during a stressful time.
You should ask about their experience with cases like yours, the types of law they practice, their strategy, who will handle your case, fees, communication style, and what sets them apart from other attorneys. These questions help ensure you hire the right lawyer for your situation.
Look for an attorney who has specific criminal law experience, regularly practices in the jurisdiction where your case is pending, communicates clearly, and aligns their strategy with your goals. Reading client reviews and asking targeted questions can also help you make an informed decision.
Every California county operates differently. Attorneys who regularly appear in local courts often have relationships with judges, prosecutors, and court staff, which can improve case outcomes and streamline communication.
Questions about communication style, who will handle your case, fee structure, strategy for your type of case, and courtroom experience help determine whether the attorney is a good fit and whether you can trust them to represent your interests effectively.
Yes. Understanding whether fees are flat or hourly, and if payment plans are available, prevents surprises later. A transparent attorney will clearly explain costs upfront.
While asking questions doesn’t directly affect the legal outcome, it helps you hire an attorney with the right experience and strategy for your case. The better the fit, the more effectively your lawyer can advocate on your behalf.